Workers Compensation Fraud Investigation Case
How Our Insurance Fraud Investigators Exposed a Fraudulent Disability Claim
Report Suspected FraudCase Overview: Irvine Workers Compensation Fraud Investigation
Professional surveillance techniques deployed during workers comp fraud investigation
This workers compensation fraud investigation demonstrates how our experienced insurance fraud investigators document fraudulent disability claims through systematic surveillance and evidence collection. An Irvine-based manufacturing company contacted FalconGate Investigations after receiving anonymous tips that an employee claiming total disability was engaging in physical activities inconsistent with their reported injuries.
Our team of licensed California insurance fraud private investigators conducted a comprehensive surveillance operation over 21 days, documenting extensive physical activities that directly contradicted the claimant's medical restrictions and sworn statements. The evidence collected resulted in claim denial, criminal referral, and significant cost savings for the employer and their insurance carrier.
Case Summary at a Glance
Client's Initial Concerns
The employer's HR department and their workers compensation insurance carrier contacted our insurance fraud investigation team after multiple red flags emerged regarding a disability claim filed eight months prior. The claimant, a warehouse supervisor, alleged a severe back injury from lifting equipment and claimed total temporary disability, unable to perform any work duties.
Red Flags Identified by Client
- Anonymous tip from coworker reporting claimant was seen doing construction work
- Social media posts showing claimant at outdoor recreational events
- Medical treatment pattern inconsistent with claimed severity
- Claimant declined all modified duty offers without medical justification
- Multiple missed Independent Medical Examination (IME) appointments
- Prior workers comp claim history at previous employer
- Claimant's reported activities to claims adjuster contradicted social media presence
- Treating physician's restrictions seemed excessive relative to diagnostic imaging
According to the California Department of Insurance Fraud Division, workers compensation fraud costs California businesses and insurers billions of dollars annually. The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) estimates that insurance fraud accounts for approximately 10% of all property-casualty insurance claims, making professional fraud investigation essential for businesses and insurers.
Our workers comp surveillance team developed an investigation plan designed to document the claimant's actual physical capabilities and daily activities while maintaining strict legal compliance and chain-of-custody protocols.
Investigation Methodology
Surveillance Strategy
Our insurance fraud private investigator team implemented a multi-phase surveillance strategy based on the claimant's known residence, reported medical appointments, and intelligence gathered from social media analysis.
Mobile Surveillance
Covert vehicle surveillance tracking subject's movements to various locations including suspected secondary employment site.
Static Surveillance
Fixed-position monitoring at residence documenting physical activities including yard work, vehicle maintenance, and recreational activities.
Video Documentation
High-definition video recording of activities inconsistent with claimed injuries and medical restrictions.
Social Media Analysis
Open-source intelligence gathering from public social media profiles documenting activities and statements.
Professional surveillance documentation during fraud investigation
Legal Compliance & Evidence Standards
All workers compensation fraud investigation activities were conducted in full compliance with California law and insurance investigation regulations. Our investigators documented all surveillance from public areas where there is no expectation of privacy. Evidence collection followed strict chain-of-custody protocols ensuring admissibility in Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) proceedings, civil litigation, and potential criminal prosecution.
Our investigators are experienced in California workers compensation law and understand the evidentiary requirements for challenging fraudulent claims. We coordinate with Special Investigations Units (SIU), defense attorneys, and law enforcement when appropriate to maximize case outcomes.
Investigation Timeline
Day 1-3: Case Assessment & Intelligence Gathering
Reviewed claim file, medical records, and claimant statements. Conducted comprehensive social media analysis revealing public posts showing subject at a youth baseball game actively participating as coach. Identified residence location and potential secondary work site from online activity. Developed surveillance schedule based on gathered intelligence.
Day 4-8: Initial Surveillance Phase
Surveillance documented claimant leaving residence and traveling to a residential construction site where subject was observed carrying lumber, operating power tools, and climbing ladders—activities directly contradicting claimed back injury restrictions. Video evidence captured over 6 hours of physical labor on first documented day alone.
Day 9-14: Pattern Establishment & Documentation
Continued surveillance confirmed pattern of undisclosed employment at construction site, working 5-6 hour days. Additional documentation captured subject performing yard maintenance including raking, lifting bags of mulch, and operating a riding lawn mower. Subject also observed carrying heavy grocery bags and loading items into vehicle without apparent difficulty.
Day 15-18: Recreational Activity Documentation
Weekend surveillance documented subject coaching youth baseball practice including throwing batting practice, hitting ground balls, and demonstrating fielding techniques. Subject observed bending, twisting, running, and performing repeated overhead throwing motions—all activities specifically prohibited by treating physician's work restrictions.
Day 19-21: Evidence Compilation & Reporting
Final surveillance sessions confirmed continued pattern of unrestricted physical activity. Comprehensive investigation report compiled including all video evidence, surveillance logs, social media documentation, and detailed activity analysis. Report delivered to client's SIU and defense counsel for claim determination and potential fraud referral.
Evidence Collected
Our workers compensation fraud investigation produced comprehensive documentation that clearly established the claimant's actual physical capabilities were far greater than represented to medical providers, the claims administrator, and the employer.
Video Surveillance
8.5 hours of high-definition video documenting physical activities including construction work, yard maintenance, sports activities, and heavy lifting.
Photographic Evidence
312 timestamped photographs documenting subject at construction site, baseball field, residence, and various locations performing restricted activities.
Social Media Documentation
Preserved screenshots and metadata from public social media posts showing recreational activities and statements inconsistent with disability claim.
Surveillance Logs
Detailed investigator notes with timestamps documenting all observed activities, locations visited, and duration of physical exertion during 84+ hours of surveillance.
Activity Analysis Report
Side-by-side comparison of claimant's documented activities versus medical restrictions, identifying 186 specific restriction violations.
Secondary Employment Documentation
Evidence of undisclosed construction work including job site identification, work hours documentation, and physical activity performed.
All evidence was collected following strict chain-of-custody protocols required for WCAB proceedings. Our investigators are available to provide deposition testimony and expert witness services when required for litigation or criminal prosecution.
Case Outcome
Fraud Investigation Successfully Resolved
The evidence gathered during this workers compensation fraud investigation provided irrefutable documentation of claim fraud. The insurance carrier and employer were able to take decisive action based on our comprehensive evidence package.
Claim Outcome: Based on surveillance evidence, the insurance carrier denied further benefits and initiated recovery proceedings for previously paid benefits. The claimant's attorney withdrew from representation after reviewing the video evidence.
Criminal Referral: Case was referred to the Orange County District Attorney's Insurance Fraud Unit for potential criminal prosecution under California Insurance Code Section 1871.4 (workers compensation fraud).
Financial Impact
The successful resolution of this disability fraud investigation resulted in significant cost savings for the employer and insurance carrier:
Beyond the direct financial savings, the investigation helped the employer send a clear message that fraudulent claims will be investigated and prosecuted, potentially deterring future fraud attempts by other employees.
Frequently Asked Questions: Workers Compensation Fraud Investigation
Suspect Workers Compensation Fraud? Act Now.
Our experienced insurance fraud investigators have saved Orange County and San Diego employers millions in fraudulent claim costs. Confidential consultations available for employers, insurers, and TPAs.
Call Now: (323) 746-1761 Request SIU ConsultationLicensed California Private Investigators | Serving Insurance Carriers, Employers & TPAs | WCAB-Admissible Evidence
Related Insurance Investigation Services
In addition to workers compensation fraud investigation, FalconGate provides comprehensive insurance investigation services throughout Orange County and San Diego for carriers, employers, self-insured entities, and third-party administrators.
Our team of licensed California insurance fraud private investigators combines decades of experience in insurance claims investigation with advanced surveillance technology. We understand the unique evidentiary requirements of insurance litigation and work closely with SIU departments and defense counsel to maximize case outcomes.
